Matt Bailey's affiliate blog

20 Jul, 2009

The beginning of the end for voucher codes?

Posted by: admin In: Uncategorized

The latest edition of the Hitwise monthly UK online roundup makes interesting reading for all of us in the affiliate industry who work with voucher codes. Robin and the team at Hitwise have been looking into the popularity of various voucher code keywords and phrases and the results point to changing consumer behaviour in this market.

Hitwise vouchers graph July 09

This graph demonstrates the decreasing nature of searches for the exact match term [vouchers], however does not take into account the fact that users are potentially being more specific when searching for deals.

So the graph below shows all searches including the term voucher.

Hitwise voucher code results July 2009

So we can see that whilst the search volumes are flattening out, they are still growing, which would seem to indicate that consumer behaviour when searching for discounts is evolving. Is this a result of a maturation of the market, with consumers becoming used to not finding certain vouchers that they have looked for so therefore refining searches to give the best chance of finding what they need?

Finally Hitwise looked at the traffic to voucher specific websites (the examples they give are MyVoucherCodes, MoneySavingExpert and HotUKDeals).

Voucher site hitwise search volumes july 2009

As we can see, the growth is not as pronounced as it has been previously but is remaining steady and growing. In fact, traffic sent to merchant sites has increased by around 25% year on year from May 2008 to May 2009.

So what does this mean? It seems that consumers are becoming more savvy in knowing how to search for discounts. It would not surprise me if this predates a movement away from user generated sites such as Money Saving Experts and Hot UK Deals towards sites which offer consumers a better experience and greater chance of success in finding a valid code.

It also begs more questions. It seems that traffic to voucher code sites is not growing at the same rate as traffic from these sites to merchants, so are voucher code sites becoming better at converting their traffic. Personally, I would like to think that the introduction of the IAB Affiliate Council’s guidelines have assisted in enhancing the quality enabling consumers to trust the space more. Is this the case?

Finally, the volumes here are huge so it isn’t an area that merchants can afford to ignore, but must use to their advantage. I would love to see some demographic data from Hitwise on the type of people using voucher code sites. We make assumptions that the type of consumer that searches for voucher codes come from the “Jeremy Kyle demographic” but I would dispute that. I would imagine that these consumers are web savvy younger consumers who understand how to use the web to their advantage.

It shows that, as has been demonstrated in the US over many years, the desire for consumers to find a better deal will not go away but needs to be managed. The market does seem to be experiencing some maturity as is bound to happen but instead of the beginning of the end the data seems to point towards a natural evolution in the use of voucher codes.

If you haven’t signed up to the Hitwise monthly newsletter, I heartily recommend that you do here

Also I recommend the book Click by Bill Tancer, who is Global Head of Research at Hitwise, a thoroughly compelling read.

Share and Enjoy:
  • Digg
  • Sphinn
  • del.icio.us
  • Facebook
  • Google Bookmarks
  • LinkedIn
  • StumbleUpon
  • Twitter

8 Responses to "The beginning of the end for voucher codes?"

1 | Kevin Edwards

July 21st, 2009 at 7:20 am

Avatar

Matt, Really interesting set of stats. I believe with maturity of the voucher code market comes different search behaviour for codes.

I have no evidence to back this up but my belief is that voucher codes have become a standalone entity; that is rather than part of a research and buy process they act as an initial trigger.

Given how the well known voucher code sites have attracted significant, loyal traffic they have in essence created their own brands that are the first port of call for savvy or price led consumers. Rather than search for a code are an increasing number of consumers using voucher code sites as their ‘search engine’, a first port of call?

If this is the case then it could actually make a stronger case for voucher codes or at the very least merchant placement within the voucher code sites.

I’ll be watching the space with interest to see how this one develops.

2 | admin

July 21st, 2009 at 7:47 am

Avatar

Think you are right Kevin and it would be good to try and get some statistics on this. The big argument with voucher code sites has been that they only enter the sales process once a customer has decided what they want to buy.

The question I would pose is has this behaviour changed, or is it simply that the method of landing on a voucher code site has changed? Traditionally a lot of traffic to voucher code sites came from search engines, people deciding which retailer to buy from and then searching for [merchant voucher code].

As the larger voucher code sites have emerged, are their regular users simply navigating directly to their preferred voucher code site instead of searching generically? This would give the impression that the VC site is adding significant value, without that necessarily being the case.

Problem is that without significant analysis of both click data and merchant data it’s impossible to measure but seems to be vital in understanding the true value.

3 | Emma Kane

July 21st, 2009 at 3:17 pm

Avatar

I suspect the poor quality of many of the voucher websites, many of which work to gaining traffic have no relevant codes is leaving the consumer disappointed and killing the search market, as savvy consumers go direct to search the forums of quality sites, rather than wasting their time on wading through google spam. Classic example of a bad user experience killing the opportunity.

4 | admin

July 21st, 2009 at 3:31 pm

Avatar

I agree to an extent Emma but think this is changing. The regulations that we brought in covering voucher code sites through the IAB are bringing increased professionalism to this industry. In addition, new entrants to the market such as vouchercodes.co.uk and discountvouchers.co.uk are raising the bar.

5 | Emma Kane

July 21st, 2009 at 4:11 pm

Avatar

Yes, they are nice sites, sadly they are not at the top of the serps – yet…The spammy site’s are still top for the couple of obvious searches I did. Hopefully they’ll all be forced to raise their game.

6 | Helen

July 22nd, 2009 at 1:16 pm

Avatar

Interesting article and stats. The voucher code market saw a rapid growth and it seems we still have a lot to learn about the sector and the customers buying process. I agree with what has been said here about customers search habits changing. Affiliates will need to continue to develop the content on voucher sites in order to make them sticky, improve the customer experience and ultimately get more customers using them. I think voucher directories will cease to exist as their value is limited, but this follows the same pattern as general affiliate sites where the most successful sites have developed from simple comparison pages to in-depth content heavy sites with large customer databases. The market will grow but conversion and retention will be key for affiliates. From a merchant point of view it would make me more comfortable working with VC sites knowing that they are adding value and prompting the customer to make a purchase rather than simply being the final port of call once the purchase decision has been made. I don’t think this is the beginning of the end, perhaps the beginning of the maturity of the sector …

7 | Jason Dale

July 24th, 2009 at 12:41 pm

Avatar

Few random points..

1. How does the graph compare to online shopping spend over the same period. Are people not visiting because they’re not spending? Has the recession had an effect on sales, and therefore on vouchers (although you could argue that with the recession more people would want discount..)

2. Codes are now everywhere (The Sun, Dennis Publishing, The Telegraph, The Mirror, on Cashback sites etc) so perhaps the need to search is greatly reduced?

3. Voucher sites did a lot of PR activity in the run up to Christmas.. so in fact are you seeing a natural balance returning when they’re not on TV, in the papers etc?

Beginning of the end… nah, just another evolution.. Darwin would be pleased.

8 | Jason Norris

July 30th, 2009 at 3:52 pm

Avatar

Its all about the IAB Affiliate Council’s guidelines I am sure Mr Bailey :)

But I agree the traffic quality is more young and savvy than a lot of people think. I have lost track of how many friends have send around the 2 for 1 meals.

Comment Form




About

Always happy to have a chat with people about anything that is written here. Follow me on twitter - www.twitter.com/mattb811